Skip to main content

Making Mistakes

As an English teacher, whenever I have a lesson online or in a classroom, I expect my students to make mistakes, and students, in turn, expect me to correct them. Mistakes are a natural and fundamental part of learning. “By seeking and blundering we learn,” to quote Goethe. But what constitutes a mistake? More specifically, what is a grammatical mistake? In order to answer that question, I am going to tell you a story about a table. 

Once upon a time, a husband and a wife bought a table from IKEA. It was a beautiful, oval coffee table in walnut veneer, or it would be once they had assembled it – and if you have ever bought furniture from IKEA, you will know that it is not always easy to put it together! When the couple returned home, they took everything out of the box and lay all the pieces of wood and the screws and the bolts on the floor. It looked fairly straightforward, and so they started to assemble the table without carefully studying the instructions. Soon they realised that something was wrong. The legs of the table were not straight. They looked at the instructions and saw that they had used the wrong type of screw.

Speaking another language is a bit like assembling furniture. You know that words go together in certain ways, but in order to express yourself effectively, you need to use grammar – the instructions which tell you how to properly form a sentence. Often I hear someone say, for example, “I very like chocolate.” It is perfectly understandable, of course, but a native speaker of English does not use the word 'very' in this way. If you want to know the reason for this, it is because 'very' modifies adjectives and adverbs only, so the phrase 'very much', or 'really', sounds better here. Better still would be “I like chocolate very much,” with the adverbial phrase placed at the end of the sentence.

In my opinion, the grammar of a language is a set of instructions rather than a set of rules – rules imply a penalty when they are broken, but there are no penalties when it comes to learning a language; there are only opportunities to learn. It is my job as a teacher to make people aware of the instructions, and to show them how words go together. It is not my job to act as a police officer and penalise students for “breaking the rules”.

Anyway, let us return to the story. Did the couple manage to assemble their table from IKEA? After consulting the instructions again over coffee, they succeeded in putting all the right screws in all the right places, and they now have a beautiful, oval coffee table standing in their living room.


The End.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Interview with a Teacher

I recently asked a colleague, whom I will call Dominic, if he would kindly answer some questions about his experiences of teaching English as a foreign language. “It's for my blog,” I told him. He eyed me suspiciously for a moment, but then said he would cooperate on the condition that I don't use his real name. So, Dominic, when did you start teaching? I answered a job advert on Dave's ESL Cafe in 2015. It was for a teaching position in a town in Poland. I'd just completed a CELTA course and I thought that teaching abroad would give me an opportunity to see more of the world. That's what I thought, anyway. Something tells me that it wasn't what you expected? The owner of the school in Poland was, to put it bluntly, a bit of a weirdo. The walls of his office were covered with photographs of various people he'd met on his travels -- hundreds of them -- and there were cameras installed in the classrooms. He routinely spied on my lessons. He didn't al...
Post a Comment
Read more

Three Tips for Learners

When not teaching English, I try to teach myself a little Spanish or Polish, the latter of which I find particularly challenging because Polish is a highly inflected language, and even simple utterances can invoke several grammar rules. Translate the sentence 'I drink green tea', for example, where there is a subject followed by a verb, an adjective and finally a noun. In Polish, you not only conjugate the verb, but also make the adjective agree with the gender of the noun AND change the endings of both of those words as they constitute the object of the verb. Do you see what people mean when they say that Polish is a hard language to learn? I know I'll never speak the language perfectly, but no one is asking me to. Therein lies a problem when it comes to language learners' expectations: Some people want perfection; they want to be fluent and flawless. Very often, though, you can't be both. You might speak English fluently, but make a lot of mistakes. On the other h...
Post a Comment
Read more

How English Has Changed

Languages evolve over time, and English is no exception. Indeed, a native speaker of English might struggle to understand someone speaking the language as it was spoken in England five hundred years ago. In this post I look at four ways in which this lingua franca of the globalised world has changed since the days it was largely confined to the island known as Great Britain. 1. Word order The order of words in a sentence typically follows a subject-verb-object pattern; however, this hasn't always been the case. Whereas now you hear people say 'Mary picked flowers', for example, some Middle English texts placed the object before the verb. This shift in word order sometimes happens today, when people exchange traditional wedding vows, the phrase 'With this ring I thee wed' being one well-known example. 2. Pronouns The pronouns 'thou' and 'thee' have fallen out of use. Nowadays, we prefer to use 'you'. It's simpler, don't you think...
Post a Comment
Read more